10:04:25 From Maria Drave (IWA) to Everyone: Good morning everyone. We will be starting very shortly. 10:06:12 From Donna Coyle, Wales Co-operative Centre to Everyone: Good morning from Donna Coyle, from the Wales Co-operative Centre. 10:06:26 From Donna Coyle, Wales Co-operative Centre to Everyone: A pleasure! 10:06:34 From Nina Ruddle to Everyone: Sunny and cold in North Wales- hello all Nina Ruddle Wrexham Glyndwr 10:07:06 From Rachel Cable - Heritage Fund to Everyone: Morning all, it's Rachel Cable here, from the National Lottery Heritage Fund. Enjoying the sun in Cardiff :-) 10:07:17 From Katie Cresswell to Everyone: Hello everyone, PHW research assistant here, soon moving over to Bangor University - Katie Cresswell 10:07:28 From John Gallanders to Everyone: Morning all John Gallanders - Independent Member of BCUHB and various Third Sector activities. 10:07:30 From Elin Hywel to Everyone: Bore da pawb o Bwllheli! ☺️ 10:07:33 From Iwan Williams to Everyone: Bore da pawb, Iwan Williams, Prifysgol Bangor / Morning all, Iwan Williams Bangor University 10:07:36 From Llinos Spencer to Everyone: Bore da bawb/ Good morning everyone. I'm Llinos Haf Spencer from Health and Care Economics Cymru, Bangor University. 10:07:39 From Kathryn Caine to Everyone: Bore da, Kathryn o Prifysgol Bnagor. Morning all! 10:07:40 From Arwel Williams to Host and Panelists: Sunny in Rhyl! I'm Arwel from the regeneration team in WG 10:08:05 From mike reay to Everyone: Good morning- Mike Reay, Adult Social Care, North Denbighshire 10:08:06 From Lowri Hughes to Everyone: Bore da bawb, Lowri Hughes Prifysgol Bangor 10:08:21 From Rhun Dafydd to Everyone: Bore da, Rhun Dafydd o'r Gronfa Gymunedol y Loteri Genedlaethol / from The National Lottery Community fund 10:08:31 From Chris Drew to Everyone: Bore da, Chris Drew, Bangor University 10:08:34 From Robat Idris to Everyone: Bore da o Ynys Môn! 10:08:38 From Kate to Everyone: Bore Da, Kate Young here North Wales Regional Caseworker from the Wales Learning Disability Helpline, Mencap Cymru :) 10:08:46 From Dr Sibani Roy to Host and Panelists: Good morning from Sibani Roy, Chair NWAMI, sorry for being late. 10:09:02 From Rachel Granger to Everyone: Bore da. Rachel Granger, health economics, Bangor University. 10:09:20 From Catherine H to Everyone: Good morning , Catherine Hirst , a student of human geography, Bangor university 10:09:22 From Clare Roberts to Everyone: Good Morning, Clare Roberts, registered manager of Haulfryn care home in Flintshire, and Bangor University student 10:09:23 From Andrew Rogers to Everyone: HI , I am Andrew, PhD researcher at Bangor (Community Health Development) AND Public Health Lecturer (Manchester and LSHTM) AND Business Consultant specialising in health promption and sustainable development in communities.......But currently in isolation in. caravan in snowy Shropshire as Covid finally got to me 10:09:37 From Jacob to Host and Panelists: Bore da pawb. Jacob Davies, CHEME, Prifysgol BAngor 10:09:42 From Abraham to Everyone: Good morning I'm Abraham Makanjuola from the Centre for Health Economics and Medicines Evaluation, Bangor University 10:09:43 From Kathryn Shared Lives Plus to Everyone: Bore da pawb - Kathryn Shared Lives Plus https://sharedlivesplus.org.uk/ 10:09:47 From Sion Jones to Everyone: Bore day / good morning from Sion Jones of LE Wales, a policy and economics consultancy 10:10:17 From Kim Cann to Everyone: Good morning! Kim Cann, Consultant in Public Health in Swansea Bay. 10:10:36 From Rhys to Everyone: Bore da o Llanddaniel Fab. 10:10:52 From Maria Drave (IWA) to Everyone: You can tweet @IWA_Wales using #IWABangor 10:10:54 From Will Henson (IWA) to Everyone: #IWABangor 10:11:06 From Arwel Williams to Everyone: Bore da o Rhyl. Arwel WG Regen Team 10:11:28 From Sarah Andrews to Everyone: Bore Da a good morning from Sarah Andrews, Public Health consultant in BCUHB Local Public Health Team. 10:12:06 From Rhys ap Gwilym to Everyone: Bore da o Llanberis. Rhys, economegydd/economist, Bangor 10:13:39 From Ed Hughes to Everyone: Bora da o Llanelwy, Ed Hughes ClwydAlyn. 10:16:59 From Dr Sibani Roy to Host and Panelists: Thank you professor Davies for presenting outcomes of search of some truths in North Wales, particularly Bangor University 10:23:05 From Will Henson (IWA) to Everyone: The North Wales Regional Economic Framework https://gov.wales/sites/default/files/publications/2021-12/north-wales-regional-economic-framework.pdf 10:34:26 From Robat Idris to Everyone: Oes yna gyfieithu ar y pryd ar gael? 10:38:22 From Kathryn Shared Lives Plus to Everyone: https://homeshareuk.org/ we are currently setting up 3 new Pilots for Wales. Helping people to remain in their own homes for longer. Sharing homes and lives. Affordable accommodation for young people and companionship with low level support for older people, keeping them well and active in their communities. 10:39:26 From Maria Drave (IWA) to Everyone: If you want to get in touch with Prof Edwards, you can follow her on twitter @ProfRTEdwards or email her on r.t.edwards@bangor.ac.uk. 10:39:34 From Nina Ruddle to Everyone: My 5 areas. 1. Invest in projects that work, take some risks to prove things work, stop measuring the wrong things and be driven by needs of communities not funders- Well being assessments are not perfect but a good place to start. 2. Support those in our organisation that experience in work poverty and the cost of living crisis needs to be addressed now - we need to act now on this 10:39:45 From Maria Drave (IWA) to Everyone: And here are the links from the presentation: 10:39:48 From Maria Drave (IWA) to Everyone: https://global.oup.com/academic/product/applied-health-economics-for-public-health-practice-and-research-9780198737483?cc=gb&lang=en& 10:39:57 From Maria Drave (IWA) to Everyone: Recent blog: Well-Becoming Wales: Health Economics and the Choices Ahead Post-Pandemic   https://cheme.bangor.ac.uk/health-blog-1.php.en 10:41:17 From Nina Ruddle to Everyone: 3. Actively listen to communities and individual narratives- stories move us to action- this has been identified in the well being assessments across the region. From Children and young people and everyone in between- links to all the other data sets - we don't need more boards we need more action that matters? 10:44:09 From Ade to Everyone: Agree with Mario on making communities more able to decide on what matters to them; the environment, the support systems, jobs etc rather than top down decisions 10:44:17 From Nina Ruddle to Everyone: 4. Participatory Budgeting - PSB don't have funds but we can work well within the 5 ways of working. lets get communities to agree where funds/ efforts and resources (where we spend our time as organisations) We are piloting a future leaders programme to support Children and Young people to shape the well being plans that address the key themes that are emerging from the Well being assessments and Population needs assessment. we have a wealth of data we need to make sense of this with all members of society and citizens across the region. 10:44:28 From John Gallanders to Everyone: Nina's point about measuring the wrong things occurs so often- often it is done because - What gets measured gets managed? if there is a problem issue that is too difficult to manage it becomes very easy to avoid by not measuing. 10:46:18 From Nina Ruddle to Everyone: 5. Focus on the unusual suspects those that don't engage, to shape what they need so we can co produce our approaches to tackle some of these huge issues we are tying to tackle - these are the voices we should actively seek out 10:50:05 From Maggie Brown to Everyone: Maggie Brown here, media journalist and Channel 4 historian, lives in Meifod, Powys and London, with family links in Dee valley, campaigned to keep local authority care home in Corwen open in 2014. Very concerned about health issues. With Shrewsbury nearest hospital for many 10:51:47 From Rachel Granger to Everyone: Da iawn Ceri, yn hollol 10:52:02 From Robat Idris to Everyone: Go dda yr hogyn. 10:52:33 From Nina Ruddle to Everyone: 6. Sorry one last one! Connect the 'systems' we operate in. It is all very complex all the public service landscape. I am really hopeful that we have amazing people doing fantastic work we need to think in whole systems/eco system to change the future. start somewhere do something, accept it is messy, connect people and create movements for change data and insight informed. 2025 social movement is a great example of this with lots of brilliant partners all trying to end health inequalities by 2025 and we are connect our civic mission to end social inequality and we are working across the region on some innovative project https://www.2025movement.org/ 10:52:41 From John Gallanders to Everyone: Central to everything are citizens - their expecation is a fully integrated Health, Social Care and Ambuance etc and dont worry about the logo on the badge for anyone who provides support - they just want the best quility services at a time they are in need. Silo delivery is not the citizens execataion. 10:53:23 From Llinos Spencer to Everyone: Syniadau gwych Ceri. 10:53:28 From Robat Idris to Everyone: Ond mi ddylan nhw fod efo cyfleustra i ti Ceri gyflwyno yn y Gymraeg. Hollol greiddiol pan ydach chi'n sôn am 'respect'. 10:54:35 From Kathryn Shared Lives Plus to Everyone: https://youtu.be/CXdXm1lA9J8 A great example of intergenerational living. Florence and Alexandra talk about their experience of Homesharing. Enabling people to move into and work within an area or indeed remain in their community of birth despite being priced out of the local housing market. 10:55:57 From Nina Ruddle to Everyone: Supporting the new curriculum to create an education system that is for the future and gives children and young people the skills then need to be active, engaged and global citizens 10:56:41 From Leena Sarah Farhat to Everyone: Hi Leena here, I live and work here in North Wales. For every young person who wants to stay in North Wales there are many who want to leave. Why should older people be pressuring young people to stay here for training if this isn't always the best place for them to be trained? 10:56:47 From Elin Hywel to Everyone: I'm affraid I totally disagree. The energy that it would take to lobby to bring big business to the north of Wales needs to be invested in the development of small businesses in Wales to fill that gap of our missing middle medium size enterprises that we know are community focused and build real structure to healthy voable communities. 10:57:15 From Nina Ruddle to Everyone: We have amazing legislation and policies in Wales that are to be proud of. We need to all implement this in the best way- there is often an implementation gap how do we address this 10:57:46 From Nia Williams o CNC/NRW to Everyone: Cytuno efo Ceri bod angen sortio systemau ynni, a bwyd yn allweddol i hyn hefyd… a bod cymunedau angen perchen asedau lleol. (energy, and food systems is key to this) 10:57:58 From Llinos Spencer to Everyone: Admin - can you please copy the chat at the end and circulate? 10:58:00 From Leena Sarah Farhat to Everyone: I agree with you Nina though many of those policies could be better adapted to the north Walian context 10:58:49 From Holly W to Host and Panelists: Hi, many thanks for this morning so far. Will a recording of this webinar be available afterwards? 10:59:22 From Leena Sarah Farhat to Everyone: Furthermore while small businesses are great we need a range of business sizes and scales for North Wales to thrive. 11:00:08 From Will Henson (IWA) to Everyone: Hi Holly. Yes, the recording will be available on our Youtube channel https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC3-xRTlyKUcBmLpo3AuSvhw 11:00:42 From Will Henson (IWA) to Everyone: Hi Llinos. Yes, we will make sure to do that and circulate along with a link to the video recording 11:03:43 From Holly W to Host and Panelists: Fantastic, many thanks for confirming Will 11:12:29 From Rachel Cable - Heritage Fund to Everyone: Great discussion so far, and really pleased to hear Ceri raising the importance of cultural activities in this story. If any organisations are seeking funding for heritage projects, do please look at what we have available through the National Lottery Heritage Fund - we offer grants from £3,000 upwards. Full details at https://www.heritagefund.org.uk/in-your-area/wales. Feel free to contact me if you'd like any further details - rachel.cable@heritagefund.org.uk. 11:12:47 From ian.mackinlay@myphone.coop to Host and Panelists: If we were at a real non-Zoom meeting now, we would be , and could be, all chatting to each other now. It does not have to be this way. I frequently chat to others during coffee breaks on Zoom meetings from other organisations. 11:13:06 From Dr Sibani Roy to John Gallanders, Host and Panelists: Professor Rhiannon, I very much appreciated your presentation. 11:17:56 From Nina Ruddle to Everyone: How can we measure prevention? so many variables to this but prevention and supporting people to not becoming ill (where possible) ? Sophie Howe's challenge to top slice 10% of the health budget to put into wellness/well becoming- is measuring prevention the only way or can we rethink how we 'measure'? 11:19:36 From ndp21shy to Everyone: Would it be feasible to map 'unconscious biases' in Wales-to establish a grounding for raising awareness? 11:20:20 From John Gallanders to Everyone: Not all migrants whether refugee, asylum seekers or Economic are directly visible as they are not always of colour. We have for many years been relient on a Health and Social Care workforce that comes from a multi national background that have been fully integarted into our communities. North Wales is a very welcoming region - same as the rest of Wales. 11:20:48 From Elin Hywel to Everyone: Thank you everyone for an interesting conversation 11:21:10 From Nina Ruddle to Everyone: Jo Seymour and Warm Wales lead healthy homes healthy people/ fuel poverty project- her team can support energy effiency but she also support 'social prescribing' for the people she visits https://www.warmwales.org.uk/about-warm-wales/ 11:22:15 From Leena Sarah Farhat to Everyone: And conversely people of colour don't always properly understand refugee plight 11:23:40 From Dr Sibani Roy to Host and Panelists: Thank you Mario 11:25:20 From John Gallanders to Everyone: For Health workers in partculr living in North East Wales their drive time to work includes a significant number of Health establsihments in North West England often paying higher wage rates than in Wales. If 45 minutes drive to work is acceptable for many it takes people into Wirral and edge of Liverpool etc. Making North wales to place of choice for employment needs addressing. 11:28:30 From John Gallanders to Everyone: Part of statment fro Eluned Morgan yesterday whuch picks up on Mario's point. She stated that this number is at around 270 patients in Aneurin Bevan UHB, who cannot be discharged because of the 70 care homes closed due to Covid-19 in the health board area. 11:29:58 From Dr Sibani Roy to Host and Panelists: Well said Prof Edwards. 11:31:28 From Ade to Everyone: At one time social care was primarily provided by local authorities based on need. Employees were remunerated with only slight variations. Shouldn't we return to a similar situation? 11:31:49 From Will Henson (IWA) to Everyone: A key point, Prof. Edwards. UK has the highest childcare costs as a proportion of income in the OECD. 30% of household income, more than housing costs for many. My childcare bill is £1000 pcm. Economic impact of grandparent care is £££ 11:32:14 From Ed Hughes to Everyone: Agree with Mario, due to LA's underfunding, care home providers in North Wales will be forced into asking for top up fees which will mean that those that cannot afford will have limited options which will lead to more hospital admissions and increasing inequalities. 11:32:34 From Dr Sibani Roy to Host and Panelists: I worked and Lived in Caerphilly for about 6 years...there is so much inequalities both socially and economically! 11:32:42 From Will Henson (IWA) to Everyone: You can read the IWA’s in depth research on Levelling Up here https://www.iwa.wales/our-work/work/report-what-does-levelling-up-mean-for-wales/ 11:33:32 From Dr Sibani Roy to Host and Panelists: Thank you Will! 11:33:39 From Will Henson (IWA) to Everyone: http://understandingwelshplaces.wales/en/ 11:34:23 From Will Henson (IWA) to Everyone: Yn Gymraeg http://understandingwelshplaces.wales/cy/map/ 11:41:03 From John Gallanders to Everyone: The term Leveling Up implies all areas will reach a defined level of prosperity and wellbeing. To achieve this means those areas that are better off will need to stagnate to allow other areas to come up to the higher level. We need to be honest about what we are trying to achieve as a minumum for everyone. The process of Levelling Up funding being controlled from Westminster rather than Cardiff Bay makes the decsion making even further away from community level whuch we have heard today as being the driver. 11:41:30 From Nina Ruddle to Everyone: Its not rambling some really important points made! thanks Ceri! 11:42:00 From Jacob to Host and Panelists: Da iawn Ceri 11:42:25 From Nia Williams o CNC/NRW to Everyone: Difyt iawn Ceri am pobl ifanc yn gadeal yr ardal am addysg ! Heb feddl am hynna or blaen. 11:43:25 From Maggie Brown to Host and Panelists: I note there Is a lot of work for skilled people, electricians,, plumbers, tree surgeons, builders. These people command high rates. 11:45:31 From Nina Ruddle to Everyone: yes absolutely really happy to do that Rhiannon! 11:45:36 From Ed Hughes to Everyone: Great points Ceri....it's depressing that 136 young people have to go elsewhere for their education each day, does nothing for building communities... 11:47:33 From Nina Ruddle to Everyone: It is also creating the right environment for social determinants of health so we don't always deal with symptoms but the causes societal etc that cause us to become ill - this is the key in prevention 11:48:01 From Leena Sarah Farhat to Everyone: Community isn't just a physical location it's cyber space too. 11:48:01 From Will Henson (IWA) to Everyone: Hi John. If you have a spare half hour then all the proposed UK Government levelling up measures are here https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/1054766/Technical_annex_-_missions_and_metrics.pdf 11:48:03 From Llinos Spencer to Everyone: Ceri - dwi wrth fy modd yn clywed am y pethau gwych sy'n digwydd ym Mlaenau. Mae adfywio economaidd sy'n cael ei arwain yn lleol (locally led economic regeneration) yn wych, ac mae dy sylwadau am ddiffyg chweched dosbarth a pobl ifanc yn gorfod gadael yr ardal yn bwysig iawn i ystyried wrth gynllunio gwasanaethau a chynnal cymunedau iach. 11:48:31 From Sion Owen to Everyone: Be nice if active travel was direct routes between places people want to go (as opposed to nice walks) and are more than a wider pavement next to a busy road - I would like to be wrong though 11:51:17 From Nina Ruddle to Everyone: How do we define leadership? Political or a nation that wants change based on social movements? Great points Mario thanks 11:52:01 From Leena Sarah Farhat to Everyone: Many active travel routes in north Wales don't connect to one another. It's impractical. 11:52:14 From Nina Ruddle to Everyone: I agree Ceri!! I think that is very important that the spend power is shifted to what matters most to people! 11:52:48 From Sion Owen to Everyone: confidence building is a huge issue - we don't think we can have agency 11:53:15 From Rob to Everyone: Agree we need more confidence as a region 11:53:19 From Nina Ruddle to Everyone: Local connected to regional I think it can work and see this happening in the work I do but it is challenging 11:53:35 From John Gallanders to Everyone: We have on paper regional Politcal representaion through Regional Members of the Senedd yet they never meet as a Board of any kind in the regional so there is no opportunity to have any form of regional politcal accountability. 11:54:53 From Kathryn Shared Lives Plus to Everyone: Asset and community based services like Shared Lives and Homeshare and our Family by Family initiative are supporting local people in their own communities. Keeping people in touch with society, gaining employment with support and learning to live well. Offering voice choice and control for all involved. 11:54:53 From Will Henson (IWA) to Everyone: You can see the videos of those three events here https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC3-xRTlyKUcBmLpo3AuSvhw/videos 11:54:59 From Leena Sarah Farhat to Everyone: Some things work best at a regional level but there is a lot of merit in local people at the table. I would challenge for example looking at 5G projects not being regional. Signal processing systems don't know where Blaenau ends and Llan starts! 11:55:01 From Will Henson (IWA) to Everyone: November 2020, indeed 11:55:43 From Dr Sibani Roy to Host and Panelists: I think Conwy Town High street is doing well by selling Welsh food and crafts etc. 11:56:10 From Caerwyn to Everyone: it would be a start for people to refer to specific places or towns and not 'North Wales'....! it sounds like a separate country sometimes 11:56:56 From Leena Sarah Farhat to Everyone: I agree, let's stop referring to South Wales as an entity as well. 11:57:12 From Will Henson (IWA) to Everyone: Our recent work on green skills, just referenced, can be found here https://www.iwa.wales/our-work/work/report-turning-rhetoric-into-reality-decarbonising-the-foundational-economy/ 11:57:44 From Leena Sarah Farhat to Everyone: Or even Cardiff an entity? It's a collection of areas as is everywhere 11:59:22 From Dr Sibani Roy to Host and Panelists: Thank you Auriol, Maria, all presenters and audience. 11:59:59 From Will Henson (IWA) to Everyone: We’d be very grateful for your feedback, particularly suggestions for other topics and how we can improve, here http://doo.vote/18187a3 12:00:23 From Rob to Everyone: Excellent session - many thanks 12:00:27 From Nina Ruddle to Everyone: Thanks so much great session! 12:00:32 From Dr Sibani Roy to Host and Panelists: I feel included now, 12:00:41 From Dr Sibani Roy to Host and Panelists: Thank You! 12:00:52 From Rachel Granger to Everyone: Diolch yn fawr. Sesiwn diddorol iawn 12:00:55 From Ceri Cunnington - Cwmni Bro Ffestiniog to Everyone: Diolch am y cyfle i cyfrannu / Thank you for the opportunity to contribute. 12:01:05 From Sion Jones to Everyone: Diolch pawb 12:01:11 From Will Henson (IWA) to Everyone: To see our range of work and get involved by joining as a member, please visit our website https://www.iwa.wales/about-us/support-us/ 12:01:17 From Kathryn Shared Lives Plus to Everyone: Diolch pawb, that was very interesting thank you 12:01:23 From Iwan Williams to Everyone: Trafodaeth da a difyr / Great and interesting debate! 12:01:25 From Kathryn Caine to Everyone: Gwych….difyr ofnadwy, diolch yn fawr iawn!Thank you everyone, a really interesting and thought provoking debate! 12:01:27 From Huw Lloyd to Everyone: Diolch yn fawr am eich syniadau difyr. 12:01:28 From Nia Williams o CNC/NRW to Everyone: Diolch yn fawr....Really interesting session and discussion 12:01:30 From Rachel Cable - Heritage Fund to Everyone: Diolch pawb. Really excellent session. 12:01:32 From Maggie Brown to Everyone: Very interesting. 12:01:33 From Maria Drave (IWA) to Everyone: Diolch everyone! 12:01:35 From ndp21shy to Everyone: Diolch yn fawr 12:01:36 From Jacob to Everyone: Diolch yn fawr 12:01:39 From Llinos Spencer to Everyone: Diolch yn fawr. 12:01:43 From Sion Owen to Everyone: Diolch!