Simon Brammer analyses the energy and non-energy benefits arising from community energy projects.
Sheep farmer Howell Williams at his farm’s 15kW hydro power plant on the Brecon Beacons, Wales. Credit: Andy Aitchison/Ashden
Community energy projects not only generate local and sustainable energy but also bring a myriad of non-energy benefits too. Benefits like much needed local jobs, local economic investment, and energy resilience to name but a few.
But all these benefits looked like they might be on the rocks when the UK government announced in December 2015 that it would reduce Feed-in Tariffs (FiTs), to a level where effectively the pipeline of new projects has stopped flowing altogether.
At Ashden we are determined that we can’t let something as good as community energy die. So with our Award winners and partner organisations we have been scratching our collective heads and starting to design, develop and test new business model ideas.
Most of the conversations so far have revolved around the idea of ‘direct supply’, providing energy directly to customers. Without FiTs it is the only way that the economics stack up.
Becoming a ‘licenced supplier’ involves jumping through endless hurdles designed for large energy companies. However, lots of hybrid versions are now under development. One of the most interesting ones – Energy Local – is being supported by Ashden Award winner TGV Hydro.
TGV Hydro is developing micro-hydro projects for private and community ownership across South Wales, working closely with the local authority to create a model of micro-hydro that could be replicated elsewhere. Local labour is used to build projects where possible, and TGV has helped a new manufacturer of micro-hydro turbines to start up. The renewable electricity generated can be sold into the national grid, so farmers and communities can diversify their incomes.
The Energy Local model
Energy Local is a social enterprise that is transforming the electricity market for local communities and small-scale renewable generation. Their mission is to support the establishment of thousands of local, not-for-profit, Energy Local Clubs that allow local renewable generation to be used locally.
Currently in the UK most domestic electricity market consumers are charged a flat price per unit, irrespective of when the electricity is used. However suppliers buy electricity at different prices at different times of day depending on the level of demand and generation available.
Large energy users who are on ‘half-hourly settlement’ can have a time of use tariff (TOUT) that offers cheaper prices at times of the day when suppliers can purchase electricity more cheaply. TOUTs are not currently widely available to domestic customers.
Although smart meters can record how much electricity domestic customers use each half hour, the market is not yet set up to use this information for their benefit.
Energy Local allows a local group of domestic customers to form themselves into a new type of organisation, an Energy Local Club (formally a local cooperative). Each member of the ELC is given a free smart meter.
The members’ half-hourly smart meter readings are combined (or ‘virtually aggregated’) so that they have a single demand profile showing the energy used at different times of day. This makes it possible for the ELC to negotiate with a licensed supplier for a time of use tariff.
But it isn’t just consumers that can be members of the Energy Local club. Local generators (roof-top PV, a local hydro or wind turbine) can also be members. The power they generate can be pooled and shared across the energy club members.
Currently, if a household or school with rooftop PV panels does not use the generation on site it is sold for around 5p/kWh. This electricity may then be sold back to a neighbour by a licensed supplier for up to 14p/kWh.
A first trial of the Energy Local model has been working in Bethesda North Wales since the end of last year. Using the output of a local hydropower generator, up to 100 households have been able to benefit from utilising the local generation, and thanks to Cooperative Energy, electricity demand that exceeds the local generation is supplied at a price that varies through the day. More expensive during the morning and evening peaks, cheaper in the middle of the day or night.
The initial results are very encouraging with significant savings to consumers and further saving available for those who are able to match demand to local generation. Matching demand to local generation is the ultimate goal – good for the distribution network as less reinforcement is needed, good for generators, and good for consumers.
So everyone benefits – sustainably generated cheap local energy that creates jobs, reduces fuel. Win win!
All articles published on Click on Wales are subject to IWA’s disclaimer.